Doomsday Book

It feels a little unfair to compare this to Blackout/All Clear because this was written years earlier and Ms. Willis has obviously improved as a writer in the intervening timespan.  However, with their both being part of her "Oxford Time Travel" series, it is hard not to.  Don't get me wrong, Doomsday Book is quite the good book, it is just not as good as Blackout/All Clear.

Instead of World War II, this story takes the time travelling protagonist to England in the Middle Ages.  Also, in this book it continues to follow the characters in the "present" as well as in the past which makes for some interesting parallel dramatic tension (though if you don't understand the difference between the Julian and the Gregorian calendar, the timeline can be a mite bit confusing).

The beginning and the ending of this are both very strong,  but I felt that it slacked off a little in the middle.  Some important things happen, for sure, but I feel that it could have been compressed.  However, the final act is wrought with emotion and a pretty moving expression of what life what probably like in that time period for some people.

Despite the slowness in the middle, I would say that the biggest problem that I had with this book was, since it was written shortly after I was born, the future that the time travelers come from no longer feels very futuristic.  There is surprisingly large number of pages devoted to one of the characters trying to find someone to stay by his phone while he goes out, which kinda broke my suspension of disbelief because he really should have a cell phone.

Like Blackout/All Clear, the strongest part of the book is the characters, heroes and "villains," they are all very well done and you really feel for them.  It would be hard to imagine a time travel story that tried so hard to emphasize the lives of everyday people that wasn't by an author of Connie Willis' caliber.  She is the only author that can consistently bring me to (at least) the verge of tears whenever she tries to.   I think that these characters will live on in my head for a long time.  (Also, there are two little girls in this book who remind me a great deal of an Arya and Sansa Stark if they lived in the actual middle ages rather than Westeros.)

That being said, the time traveler in this book seemed a little less competent at her job then those in Blackout/All Clear (last comparison, I promise), she is much freer with information that she is from the future than the other books' protagonists.  She is also a lot quicker to give up hope than the others.  To be fair, she is less experienced than at least some of the characters in the other books so she has that rationalization going for her.

Overall, I would give this book a 93%.

Blackout/All Clear

My introduction to Connie Willis was different from many of my introductions to other authors.  Last year, I was in my computer science class waiting for it to start and the professor was making small talk with the students in the front row.  I was, of course, reading.  Suddenly, something caught my ear and I looked up to see the professor on Wikipedia looking a the book Passage by Connie Willis and talking about how much he liked it.  He then went on to look at A Fire Upon the Deep by Vernor Vinge and The Lifecycle of Software Objects by Ted Chiang.  Having read all three by now, I can authoritatively say that all three are good books.

A few weeks ago, I learned that Connie Willis was going to be giving a talk and signing books near where I live.  Since I had enjoyed Passage so much I thought she would be interesting to hear speak and it would be fun to have my book signed by the author.  A few days later, I was in Elliot Bay Books in Seattle (one of the best new book stores I have ever been in) and in their award winning science fiction section they had a Connie Willis book entitled Blackout.  Since I was already going to see her (and already going to spend a good portion of my paycheck at Elliot Bay), I decided to pick it up and try to read it before the signing. 

Upon starting it, I discovered that the book was actually part of a duology, the second part entitled All Clear.  The duology was meant to be one book but, unlike some authors I could name, Connie Willis has some sort of compunction about publishing 1000+ page paperback books.  It seems that the only people who make a distinction between the two books are publisher.  Everyone I have talked to about them, including her, refers to them as "Blackout All Clear".  The two books even read better as one, just pick up All Clear as soon as you finish Blackout.  I cannot imagine waiting in between these. Therefore, I am going against the usual format of reviewing books one at a time and am reviewing this duology as a single entity (that, and I couldn't put them down long enough to write a review about just the first book).

The story, like many stories before it, is about time travel.  The premise is that, in the year 2060 Oxford is sending historians back in time to study the past and report on it.  The story's three main characters are all sent back to England near the beginning of World War II.  It is a fantastic rendition of the war from a British civilians perspective.  However, you do not have to know about WWII to enjoy this book; the characters are marvelous and easy to relate to.

In the vast majority of books that I read, I am able to maintain a steady distance, I suspend my disbelief, but rarely do characters emotional trauma bother me after I put the book down.  This book was the complete opposite of that.  When characters in the book argued it would stress me out, let alone when they were put in life threatening situations.  I found myself crying at the (rather emotional) ending of the series.

I don't want to give away too much of the story, but I have to say that it is, so far, my favorite book of 2012.  There is something in this book for everyone, be they history buffs, sci-fi fans, character lovers, or what have you.  It was clearly painstakingly researched and well thought out.  Having met the author, I can say that she is also an excellent human being and I will be reading more of her books in the future.  When she signed my copies of the books she put little Brittish WWII slogans above the signature; stuff like "Keep calm and carry on" and "Do your bit!"

At the signing, there was also a question and answer session.  I don't remember the question that was asked to provoke this response, but she admitted that she had to rewrite the almost the entire story when she got halfway through because she decided that she had the wrong ending.  When she was signing my books, I asked her what the "wrong ending" would have been and she was gracious enough to tell me.

Overall, I would give this duology a 98%.